table of contents
How to design incentives that motivate — not demoralize.
Sales compensation is supposed to drive performance.
But too often, it drives resentment instead.
When a plan rewards the wrong behaviors or changes midstream, it doesn’t just hit your numbers — it hits your credibility.
Because in sales, pay isn’t just pay.
It’s recognition. It’s trust. It’s proof that leadership values contribution.
And once that trust is broken, no amount of bonus promises can fix it.
Incentives That Actually Work
In some cases, adjusting compensation is appropriate — as long as it’s done thoughtfully. The goal isn’t to pay more or less, but to incentivize the right behaviors.
Here are the fundamentals every comp plan should support:
Revenue Growth – Reward reps for hitting or exceeding quota. Growth is still the lifeblood of any business.
Profitability – Encourage reps to protect margins and avoid unnecessary discounting. Reward smart selling, not just volume.
Upsell & Cross-Sell – Sales doesn’t end with a signature. Recognize those who expand relationships and grow existing accounts.
Customer Retention & Renewals – Incentivize long-term commitments. A rep who retains customers saves you far more than a rep who churns them.
Strategic Focus Areas – Whether it’s new markets, new products, or multi-year deals, use your comp plan to guide the team’s attention toward what matters most.
These are the right levers. The problem comes when leadership tries to “optimize” too much.
Why Trust Is Priceless
Numbers can be fixed. Spreadsheets can be adjusted. Plans can be restructured.
But trust?
Once you break it, it’s gone.
And when salespeople lose trust in leadership, the best ones leave first. They’ll take their book of business, their pipeline, and their momentum somewhere they feel valued.
That’s why a well-designed compensation plan isn’t just a finance document — it’s a retention strategy.
How to Build a Plan That Works
If you’re designing (or revising) your comp plan, here’s how to get it right:
✔️ Stress-Test It Early
Before you launch, model different scenarios. What happens if a rep massively overperforms? What if they only hit 60% of quota? You need to be able to live with both outcomes. If the plan “breaks” under success, it’s the wrong plan.
✔️ Limit Changes
Salespeople can adapt to small tweaks — a few percentage points here or there. But if you’re constantly rewriting the rules, they’ll stop trusting the system. Make changes sparingly, and tie them to strategy, not convenience.
✔️ Protect Your Top Performers
Your top 20% probably bring in 80% of total revenue. If the plan punishes them for being too good, you’re undermining your biggest growth engine. It’s almost always cheaper to pay an extra few points than to replace elite talent.
✔️ Keep It Simple and Transparent
If a rep needs a finance degree to calculate their commission, the plan has failed. Compensation should be easy to understand, predictable, and clear. Confusion kills motivation.
✔️ Balance Fixed and Variable Pay
Reps love incentives, but they also have bills to pay. A well-balanced plan provides stability while still rewarding performance. The goal is confidence, not volatility.
✔️ Incorporate Non-Monetary Rewards
Money motivates, but recognition retains. Public praise, awards, career growth, and unique experiences can reinforce high performance without adding line items to payroll.
The Takeaway
A comp plan isn’t just math — it’s psychology.
The right plan inspires. The wrong one demoralizes.
If your team feels like they have to fight the system instead of win within it, you’ve already lost the battle.
Remember: It’s better to overpay once than to break trust forever.
Because high-performing salespeople don’t just chase money — they chase fairness.
And when they feel valued, they’ll deliver value in return.
We help companies audit and upgrade their hiring systems — not to tick DEI boxes, but to uncover the talent they’re currently missing.
